Community averages
- Strength4.2
- Body4.8
- Flavor4.2
- Construction4.8
What did you think of it?
Pick a star rating
Similar Scores
- La Flor Dominicana 30 Years ChiselLa Flor Dominicana 30 Years ChiselLa Flor Dominicana93
- Aladino 85 Aniversario Reserva ToroAladino 85 Aniversario Reserva ToroAladino93
- Cohiba AmbarPlaceresCohiba96
- Sancho Panza BelicosoCuban marcaSancho Panza93
- Nasser The Goat By A.J. Fernandez ToroNasser The Goat By A.J. Fernandez ToroA.J. Fernandez92
- Padron 1964 Anniversary Imperial NaturalImperialPadrón92
- La Aroma de Cuba Robustocore lineLa Aroma de Cuba92
- Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro RobustoMelanio MaduroOliva93
OneOff OneOff Black Toro
OneOffIllusione OneOff — Black (Toro)Toro (6" × 52)
6 x 52
Toro
Nicaraguan
-
After Aging Re-Score
Scores from major publications over time (not community ratings).
Critic reviews
The pros
Publication ratings plus staff critic voices. Want to contribute as a critic? Apply Here.
CriticHalfwheel
Published Mar 2026
After extended rest the profile centers on unsweetened cocoa and roasted peanut, with brownie-like richness on the nose and espresso anchoring the mid-palate. Earlier charred-meat edges have softened into a smoother, still-full arc.
91 critic score
Go to Full Review
CriticCigar Aficionado
Published Jan 2026
Sweet-salt tension: almond paste and white pepper over leather and toasted grain, with rustic depth rather than flash.
94 critic score
Go to Full Review- Critic
Cigar Aficionado
Published Dec 2025
Brilliant sweet-and-spicy array: marzipan, white pepper, leather, and hearty grains with rustic depth.
94 critic score
Go to Full Review
Community reviews
The smokers
Member ratings and notes from the community.
Diana
Verified purchase5/5Strength 4Body 5Flavor 5Construction 5Compared notes with a friend on the OneOff Black Toro — we both had clean draws and about the same timing through each third.
May 12, 2026
Ethan
Verified purchase5/5Strength 5Body 5Flavor 5Construction 5Quiet Sunday with OneOff Black Toro. Retrohale had more spice than the palate, which I liked.
Mar 25, 2026
Janet
Verified purchase5/5Strength 5Body 5Flavor 5Construction 5Paired OneOff Black Toro with a dark lager; the malt and the cigar's cocoa notes lined up nicely.
Feb 5, 2026
Big
Verified purchase4/5Strength 3Body 5Flavor 3Construction 5OneOff Black Toro: good marriage of strength and sweetness for my taste. Would buy again.
Dec 19, 2025
Carlos
Verified purchase4/5Strength 4Body 4Flavor 3Construction 4The OneOff Black Toro impressed on construction. Flavor was a touch lighter than I expected from the scores but still enjoyable.
Nov 1, 2025
Cigar info
- Brand
- OneOff
- Line
- Illusione OneOff — Black (Toro)
- Vitola
- Toro