Community averages

  • Strength
    5.0
  • Body
    5.0
  • Flavor
    5.0
  • Construction
    5.0

What did you think of it?

Pick a star rating

 

Privada Cigar Club A.A. Brugger (Remake) Aged 2+ Years

Privada Cigar ClubA.A. Brugger (Remake) Aged 2+Robusto (5" × 50)

100%5.0 / 5 stars
PrivadaCOMMUNITY2 Verified Ratings
-
CRITICS0 Reviews
Purchase
Flavor Notes: Chocolate syrup, tropical fruits, cream, oak, cherry wood, white and black pepper Pairing Notes: Tropical trail mix, dried tropical fruits, scotch (non-Islay), Jack Daniels, fruit punch, wine coolers, fruity seltzers, root beer Manufacturer: Privada Cigar Club Exclusive Privada Storytelling History has a way of circling back when passion meets heritage. Clark Thornton, a name familiar to many in the Privada family, discovered that his great-grandfather once ran a cigar company and shop in Erie, Pennsylvania called A.A. Brugger . From the early 1900s into the 1960s, A.A. Brugger was a staple of Erie’s cigar culture, celebrated for its dark, Pennsylvania-grown wrapper—the same broadleaf that would later rise to fame across the industry. Privada has recreated this lost legacy, resurrecting A.A. Brugger in a modern form while remaining true to its Pennsylvania roots. Where once Cuban filler was used, this remake now relies on Nicaraguan tobaccos, marrying American tradition with Nicaraguan boldness. The result is not just a cigar—it’s a living link to a family story and a tribute to American cigar history. Flavor Journey First Third: Chocolate syrup and creamy smoke hit the palate, layered with faint dried Italian herbs, oak, and white pepper. Retrohale delivers sharp white pepper, cream, and wood, while tropical fruit notes like banana and mango flash across the background. Second Third: The pepper evolves from white to black as cocoa deepens. Fruit becomes more pronounced, evoking chocolate-covered cherries. Cherry wood, cream, and minerals tingle the tongue, joined by fleeting tropical sweetness and rich tobacco undertones. Final Third: A crescendo of tropical fruit and creamy milk chocolate leads the way. Pineapple-like zest and mineral brightness pop against the backdrop of white and black pepper. Notes of firewood and oak ground the experience, closing with a bold and memorable finish. Why It Belongs in Privada The A.A. Brugger remake is more than a cigar—it’s a resurrection. By reviving Clark Thornton’s family heritage, Privada bridges cigar history with modern craftsmanship. This cigar embodies what the Privada movement is all about: uncovering lost treasures, honoring tradition, and reimagining them for today’s discerning smoker.
Size

5 x 50

Vitola

Robusto

Wrapper

Broadleaf

Binder

Pennsylvania Broadleaf

What to know

Critics consensus

No publication scores are linked for this cigar yet. When critic ratings are added, a short consensus line will appear here.

Read critic reviews

Community says

"I am unsure how they do it, but it’s another banger from Privada. What a smoke! Starts out very straightforward, but more complex as you go. Look no further than Privada!" — Dean

Read community reviews

Critic reviews

The pros

Publication ratings plus staff critic voices. Want to contribute as a critic? Apply Here.

Community reviews

The smokers

Member ratings and notes from the community.

  • Dean

    Verified purchase
    5/5

    I am unsure how they do it, but it’s another banger from Privada. What a smoke! Starts out very straightforward, but more complex as you go. Look no further than Privada!

    Nov 20, 2025

  • Brian

    Verified purchase
    5/5

    A bold, med-full bodied smoke that is a Privada exclusive remake of the classic A.A. Brugger Pennsylvania Broadleaf Maduro. This is a 5 x 50 Robusto that has been aged 2+ years from the good people at Privada. I got notes of cream and oak with a peppery bite (which I love) on the retrohale. Adding another one of these to my next purchase. A must smoke!

    Sep 30, 2025

Cigar info

Brand
Privada Cigar Club
Line
A.A. Brugger (Remake) Aged 2+
Vitola
Robusto
Factory
Privada Cigar Club Exclusive
MSRP
$10.00
Shop