
Community averages
- Strength4.5
- Body4.5
- Flavor4.5
- Construction4.5
What did you think of it?
Pick a star rating
Sinistro Cigars Sinistro Plata y Plomo
Sinistro CigarsSinistro Plata yLancero
90%4.5 / 5 stars
PrivadaCOMMUNITY2 Verified Ratings
-
CRITICS0 Reviews
Flavor Notes: Oak, cedar, red pepper, sourdough toast, leather, cinnamon, yeast, dark cola, black cherry syrup, honey, jasmine florals, marshmallow phantom sweetness, lime, cereal grains
Pairing Notes: Bourbon, Jack Daniels, cognac, amber lagers, Belgian beers, pies, pastries, coffee with cream and sugar, Lindt truffles, vanilla chocolate, after sushi with wasabi
Manufacturer: La Aurora (for Sinistro Cigars)
Privada Storytelling
The phrase Plata y Plomo —silver or lead—was made infamous by Pablo Escobar. Either you took the money, or you took the bullets. Sinistro Cigars leaned into this duality when creating Plata y Plomo , a cigar that walks the line between elegance and danger. The band itself is a masterpiece: one half adorned with peace, coins, and sunlight, the other with bullets, fire, and war. It’s not just a cigar—it’s a declaration.
Blended at the legendary La Aurora factory in the Dominican Republic, this cigar draws from one of the oldest and most labor-intensive tobacco traditions in the world: Andullo . Wrapped in banana leaves and fermented for months, Andullo tobacco adds a richness and depth that can’t be found elsewhere. James of Sinistro spent four months perfecting this blend , layering Connecticut Shade’s smooth elegance with the bold, earthy power of Andullo. The result is a cigar that feels both refined and dangerous, like sipping cognac with one hand and rolling dice with the other.
Flavor Journey
First Third: Opens with oak, cedar, red pepper, sourdough toast, yeast, and cinnamon , creating a savory, full-flavored profile. A touch of leather lingers while the retrohale carries spice and cereal grains.
Second Third: Expands into cedar, dark cola, black cherry syrup, minerals, and salt . At times the cedar shifts to oak, and a curious marshmallow-like sweetness appears, balancing the intensity with unexpected softness.
Final Third: Finishes with jasmine florals, honey, syrupy sweetness, corn, hay, and cinnamon , before revealing an intriguing lime and black walnut nuance. Bold yet elegant, it closes with power and grace.
Why It Belongs in Privada
Plata y Plomo embodies everything Privada stands for: heritage, risk-taking, and bold storytelling. This cigar could only exist because of Privada’s pursuit of the rare and unique. Andullo tobacco is rarely seen in premium cigars—it’s too costly, too time-consuming, too unconventional. But Sinistro and La Aurora brought it to life here, and with years of controlled aging, it’s matured into something unforgettable. This is a Privada-only creation, a cigar you will not find anywhere else, and a perfect example of how deep we go to bring you experiences beyond the mainstream.
Size
-
Vitola
Lancero
Wrapper
Connecticut Shade
Binder
Dominican Republic
Critic reviews
The pros
Publication ratings plus staff critic voices. Want to contribute as a critic? Apply Here.
No critic reviews yet.
Community reviews
The smokers
Member ratings and notes from the community.

Bigzig77
Verified purchase4/5Nice little blend here. Very creamy and cedary throughout. Not overly complex, but a nice mild blend. Enjoyable.
Dec 23, 2025

Mark
Verified purchase5/5This is a delicious cigar. The flavor profile throughout is a experience that you do not want to miss out on. The cigar is such a smooth smoke.
Dec 9, 2025
Cigar info
- Brand
- Sinistro Cigars
- Line
- Sinistro Plata y
- Vitola
- Lancero
- Factory
- LA Aurora (for Sinistro Cigars)
- MSRP
- $12.00



