
Community averages
- Strength4.0
- Body4.0
- Flavor4.0
- Construction4.0
What did you think of it?
Pick a star rating
Privada Cigar Club Evil Eye Aged 2+ Years
Privada Cigar ClubEvil Eye Aged 2+Toro (6" × 52)
80%4.0 / 5 stars
PrivadaCOMMUNITY1 Verified Ratings
-
CRITICS0 Reviews
Flavor Notes: Sarsaparilla, vanilla cream, rye bread, freeze-dried strawberry, cedar, lemon zest, shortbread
Pairing Notes: Brie cheese with French bread, strawberry shortcake, Spanish red wine, cognac, vanilla chai tea, root beer, assorted chocolates
Manufacturer: Tabacos de Costa Rica
Privada Storytelling
The Evil Eye Aged 2+ Years draws upon one of the most enduring symbols in history—an ancient talisman said to ward off misfortune—reimagined here as a cigar for the discerning smoker. Privada Cigar Club, always at the intersection of story and smoke, presents this Costa Rican creation as a marriage of tradition and superstition. From Costa Rica’s lush valleys to the expert hands of master rollers, the Evil Eye has rested patiently, aging for over nine months in the factory before another long repose in our vaults.
In the end, what you light is not just a cigar, but a symbol—an emblem of resilience, luck, and craftsmanship. The Evil Eye finds its way from ancient folklore to your humidor, proving that some legends don’t just endure; they evolve.
Flavor Journey
First Third: Opens with a swirl of sarsaparilla, thyme, and rye bread, underpinned by vanilla and powdered sugar. White peppercorn lingers while the retrohale delivers red pepper spice.
Second Third: Flavors converge into a culinary experience—oregano, olive oil, brie cheese, and lemon zest—balanced by a sweet cream note and freeze-dried strawberries, with cedar rounding out the profile.
Final Third: Strawberries and cream dominate, evolving into a shortbread finish reminiscent of strawberry shortcake. Notes of citrus zest, sourdough bread, and light roast coffee close out the experience with finesse.
Why It Belongs in Privada
The Evil Eye embodies what Privada stands for—rare aging, storytelling, and symbolism. It’s more than a cigar; it’s a statement piece, merging old-world superstition with new-world craft. This cigar’s time in rest brings depth that only patience can provide, making it a must-have for collectors and aficionados seeking both a great smoke and a story to share.
Size
6 x 52
Vitola
Toro
Wrapper
Brazilian Norte Mata Fina
Binder
Costa Rican
Critic reviews
The pros
Publication ratings plus staff critic voices. Want to contribute as a critic? Apply Here.
No critic reviews yet.
Community reviews
The smokers
Member ratings and notes from the community.

Bigzig77
Verified purchase4/5This is a good stick. It’s nice to have the Costa Rican blend, which is off the beaten path of normal blends. The burning construction are wonderful and the finish is mostly a light cedar with a touch of white pepper on the retrohale . Not very complex, but still great. I’ll stick with either a single or a five pack on these.
Nov 30, 2025
Cigar info
- Brand
- Privada Cigar Club
- Line
- Evil Eye Aged 2+
- Vitola
- Toro
- Factory
- Tabacos DE Costa Rica
- MSRP
- $12.00










