
Community averages
- Strength4.8
- Body4.8
- Flavor4.8
- Construction4.8
What did you think of it?
Pick a star rating
Privada Cigar Club Privada Cookies Series
Privada Cigar ClubPrivada CookiesRobusto (5" × 54)
5 x 54
Robusto
-
-
Critic reviews
The pros
Publication ratings plus staff critic voices. Want to contribute as a critic? Apply Here.
No critic reviews yet.
Community reviews
The smokers
Member ratings and notes from the community.

Kent
Verified purchase5/5Great cigar! A 95-96 all day long!!
Mar 15, 2026

Garett
Verified purchase5/5Super fast shipping and I enjoyed the personalized note. Cigar was very clean and excellent flavor. Easy draw and no burn issue. Will definitely order more from Privada.
Mar 11, 2026

Nathan
Verified purchase5/5Absolutely amazing cigar I love these cigars also my first purchase I’m impressed by the amazing quality and taste profiles I paired them with some great coffee and a homemade chocolate chip cookie 🍪 it really blew me away! I’m definitely getting more
Mar 6, 2026

Ernest
Verified purchase5/5Great stick. Thoroughly enjoyed it. Will definitely be ordering more of the same. Thanks again!
Feb 19, 2026

Christopher
Verified purchase5/5Great cigars can't a little aged to puff on
Feb 18, 2026

David
Verified purchase5/5I loved this cigar. It wasn’t as sweet asI expected. It was a more nuanced experience. I will definitely be buying a few more
Jan 29, 2026

Gerardo
Verified purchase4/5You can taste the edible notes of vanilla 😋
Jan 14, 2026

Teresa
Verified purchase5/5I really enoyed the smoothness of the stick
Jan 6, 2026

Joe
Verified purchase5/5Waves of sweet cookie goodness with outstanding construction! The Maduro is my favorite of the 3, (in my top 10 of the year) but they are all incredible. A part of my rotation in the humidor moving forward!
Dec 24, 2025

Dean
Verified purchase5/5Not sure how you do it… first third not really impressive, second third actually tasted like cookies, last third was like eating slightly burned cookies…. Amazing experience. Thanks.
Dec 14, 2025

Quadfather
Verified purchase5/5STUPENDOUS Maduro!!!! I am constantly blown away, thank you Brian & Privada!!! I picked up 18 more on Black Friday!
Dec 6, 2025

Gianni
Verified purchase5/5Absolutely amazing cigars and brand! Really cares bout there customers and there products! Highly recommend it to people!
Dec 2, 2025

Michael
Verified purchase5/5I'm a maduro man and these are great. Dark chocolate powder and creamy smoke. Lasted a hour and change. I'm getting a box of these without a doubt. Pairs well with the privada coffee.
Nov 21, 2025

Henry
Verified purchase5/5What an excellent Smoke AJ Fernandez you rule!!
Nov 10, 2025

Leroy
Verified purchase5/5The Maduro is a cookie lovers dream! This cigar is a great smoke all the way to the nub! I will definitely be getting more. As well as trying the Connecticut and the Habano.
Nov 9, 2025

Alan
Verified purchase5/5It was one of the best Connecticut cigars I’ve had in awhile.
Nov 3, 2025

Jon
Verified purchase3/5Grabbed a box of the Connecticut sticks. Decent value. Muted flavor but hard to expect a ton with the ROI. I’ve had 5 of them and the draws have been so aggressively open that it creates a very arid mouthfeel.
Oct 11, 2025

Patrick
Verified purchase5/5Excellent Connecticut!!! I really like a good Connecticut, and the Cookie is great. The only way it can be better is add an inch, and to make it even better add two inches.
Oct 1, 2025

Jason
Verified purchase5/5So delicious. Smoked to perfection- no touch ups needed. One of the best cigars out there.
Sep 26, 2025
Cigar info
- Brand
- Privada Cigar Club
- Line
- Privada Cookies
- Vitola
- Robusto
- Factory
- AJ Fernandez, Estelí, Nicaragua
- MSRP
- $25.00










